Wine Spectator:
92 points Batar 2007 (højeste nogensinde for vinen!)
"An intense, minerally nose, with notes of bitter almond, sultana and ripe melon, leads to a full-bodied palate, with rich mineral character and lemony acidity. There's a velvety, almost tannic texture on the long finish. Compact. Powerful and impressive."

Wine Advocate / A. Galloni:
95 points Camartina 2006
"The estate's 2006 Camartina (70% Cabernet Sauvignon, 30% Sangiovese) is awesome in the way it marries considerable ripeness with a firm, classic sense of structure. Black cherries, minerals, menthol, tar and subtle French oak are some of the nuances that emerge from the 2006 Camartina. This is a decidedly big, powerful Camartina that will require some patience, but all of the ingredients are there for this to be one of the finest versions of this wine ever made. I remember visiting Querciabella in late 2006. At the time estate manager Cesare Turini and Oenologist Guido De Santi were thrilled with the quality of their harvest, which had been saved by a spell of cool weather towards the end of the growing season. Tasting the Camartina it is easy to see why; this wine has it all. Anticipated maturity: 2012-2021. "

91 points Batar 2007
"Querciabella's Batar (50% Pinot Blanc, 50% Chardonnay) is quite possibly the most elegant, refined white being made in Tuscany today. Those qualities are on display in the sublime 2007. Ripe, succulent peaches, apricots, smoke, honey, spices and sweet toasted oak all come together with unusual grace. The oak is especially well-balanced in this vintage. Simply put, the 2007 Batar is a gem. Anticipated maturity: 2009-2017. "

90 points Querciabella Chianti Classico 2007
"The 2007 Chianti Classico Querciabella is a fragrant, perfumed red. Silky tannins frame a core of cherries, sweet spices and tobacco as this elegant wine opens up in the glass and puts on weight with air. In recent years the Querciabella has established itself as one of Tuscany's top Chianti Classicos, as it is again in 2007. The Querciabella is 95% Sangiovese and 5% Cabernet Sauvignon. Anticipated maturity: 2010-2017. "

The Wine Advocate
95 points Camartina 2004
93 points Camartina 2003
"At the risk of sounding like a broken record, the 2003 Camartina is a drop-dead gorgeous effort. Fat, rich and opulent, it will reward consumers with its generous super-ripe fruit, great length and beautiful overall balance...It is a very refined effort in this vintage...The estate's 2004 Camartina is another irresistibly sexy wine. A deeply-colored ruby, it displays captivating aromatics along with notes of blackberries, blueberries, violets and graphite that emerge on its medium-bodied frame. The fine tannins make it a highly enjoyable wine even at this early stage, but my experience suggests that another few years of bottle age are needed for the wine to integrate its oak and express its full range of aromas and flavors. It is a terrific effort from Querciabella...What a joy it is to taste the 2005 Chianti Classico. A model of elegance, it presents a beautiful, lively color along with generous amounts of fruit on a supple frame, with superb length, fine tannins and stunning overall balance. "

Gambero Rosso
3 Glas til Camartina 2005 ,3 Glas til Camartina 2004, 3 Glas til Camartina 2003, 3 Glas og 96 points til Camartina 2001, 3 glas til Camartina 2000...

Veronelli
95 points Camartina 2001
94 points Camartina 2000
93 points Camartina 2003
92 points Palafreno 2001
90 points Batar 2002

"La Guida della Guide Vini"
Camartina 2000 - Italiens bedste vin!
"La Guida della Guide Vini" - Guidernes guide - som samler resultaterne fra de fem førende italienske vinguider (Gambero Rosso, Veronelli, Guide dellEspresso, AIS og Maroni) har sat Camartina 2000 på førstepladsten blandt alle italienske vine med en gennemsnitsscore på 9,5 af 10. Vingården har tilegnet denne pris til den desværre nyligt afdøde stifter af vingården Guiseppe Castiglioni.